An Orphan's Promise; A Christmas Story


Ruby has a plan, and she has convinced the headmistress at the orphanage that it will work. With the winter winds blowing and after four days' journey, Ruby reaches the Kloss house. She immediately volunteers to work as a carpenter's apprentice. It is 1910, and girls do not become carpenters. But Mrs. Kloss has her own thoughts on the subject! Ruby has found a place in the world. But is it her home?

Reader Enjoyment Factors:

This holiday chapter book offers characters with depth, and artfully weaves a number of Christmas themes together: Christ's birth, Santa, the legend of the reindeer, and the true spirit of Christmas.

Content Awareness Factors:

There are some loose ends that take away from this book's potential. Unless you read the book jacket, you don't know the story is set in 1910. On the first page, Ruby encounters a teenager (the only other girl in the story), but we never hear about her again. Later in the book the passage of time is marked by a turn of the page, not a chapter separation. The time leaps are too big for that subtle a plot shift.

Parent Reaction

I couldn't put the book down. Although it seems awkward in spots, I found the story enchanting and Ruby captivating. It is easy to recognize the characters (even peripheral ones) as humans on a journey of discovery. I loved the independence that Mrs. Kloss and Ruby have in deciding what is/isn't "boys work." The illustrations (albeit not always well placed) are incredibly beautiful. They complement the story and add whimsy, as well.

Type of Book:
This is a holiday chapter book about personal discovery, faith, and family.
Educational Themes:

Although there is a Christmas theme to the book, its value goes beyond the season. The characters, their choices and journey (both adult and child characters) offer plenty to talk about. There is a Norwegian folksong,which can be the launchpad for studying legends, folklore, and customs or traditions. There are also plot elements that are subtly introduced that kids can look for as they read or listen.

Reading Level:
Recommended Age To Read By Yourself:
7 to 12
Recommended Age To Read Together:
5 and Up
Purchase Recommendation:
Buy. This is a beautiful story that offers weaves the legends of youth (flying reindeer) with the true spirit of Christmas. It will take several readings to appreciate all the book has to offer.

Title An Orphan's Promise: A Christmas Story
Author Dan J. Davis
Publisher Second Star Creations © 2006
Illustrators Christina E. Siravo
ISBN 9780972597753
Material Hard Cover
Cost $14.95
Genres Family, Holidays, Religion
Reminder: Cover images, and links are affiliate links. The Reading Tub can earn income via purchases made via these links. 100% of any income goes directly to our literacy mission.
Other Reviews:

You May Also Like...

Check out these books you may also like


Gail Buyske
Vernissage Press © 2005


Dan T. Davis
Second Star Creations © 2004
be the star you are


Richard Ross
Blue Fox Press © 2005