Edgar, Allen, And Poe And The Tell-tale Beets


Mom isn't a very good cook, but if they don't eat their dinner, Edgar, Allan and Poe can't have dessert. So bottoms up for squishy squash, liquidy liver, brussel sprouts and those smelly beets. When Edgar discovered a loose floorboard, the boys launched a plan. Dinner was "gone" and they got great desserts ... until the floor gives way and gives them away. 

Young Reader (8):
There were lots of ew-yuks and oh-no's as we read this book! Every time we read this book. My daughter loved the gross-sounding meals, the silly ploys, and, of course, the exploding floor!

Parent Perspective:
I'm betting that my daughter will remember this book when it comes time to read Poe's The Tale of the Tell-Tale Heart. This is a really fun book, and the author has everything covered in this tribute-come-spoof of the more famous macabre tale. She did a fabulous job balancing the spreads, with a short sentence on one page and a paragraph or two on the other half. The illustrations are detailed enough to keep kids exploring while you are reading some of the longer pages.

Reader Enjoyment Factors:

Humor, colorful illustrations, and a story about gross vegetables are sure to garner multiple reads in this fun book for pre-readers and transitional readers alike.

Content Awareness Factors:

If you don't like stories with less-than-model parents, you may not appreciate this story. It is not overdone, but air-headed/dense parents are a mainstay, and if you're looking for a change, now is not the time to pick this book.

Type of Book:
This picture book offers a kid-friendly twist on the famous story about hiding things.
Educational Themes:

This is a story that's meant to be shared for fun. It might be fun to read it as a complement to Poe's original ... but only with older readers ... to show them what a literary spoof is.

Reading Level:
Recommended Age To Read By Yourself:
8 to 10
Recommended Age To Read Together:
4 to 9
Age of child:
Read with a girl nearly 8 years old.
Purchase Recommendation:
Borrow, at least. This is fun to read. With liquid beets flying everywhere, the kids will definitely want to read it more than once.

Title Edgar, Allen, and Poe and the Tell-Tale Beets
Author Natalie Rompella
Publisher Lobster Press © 2009
Illustrators Francois Ruyer
ISBN 9781897550175
Material Hard Cover
Cost $19.95
Genres Family, Humor
Reminder: Cover images, amazon.com and indiebound.org links are affiliate links. The Reading Tub can earn income via purchases made via these links. 100% of any income goes directly to our literacy mission.
Other Reviews:

You May Also Like...

Check out these books you may also like


Joe Spooner
Arnica Publishing, Inc. © 2007


Julie Baer
Bollix Books © 2003


Andy Rash
Arthur A. Levine Books , Imprint Scholastic Inc. © 2009