shlemiel crooks

Summary:

Elias Olswanger owned a store that sold kosher wine and spirits in St. Louis. In 1919, just before Passover, two crooks tried to rob his store in the middle of the night. When a neighbor heard some noise, he woke other neighbors...all while Elias was sleeping at temple. When he got home, the crooks were gone, and he had a new horse and wagon. Passover was save.

Educational Themes:

The author built this story around her family history, using documents about her great-grandfather Elias Olsschwanger. Why not use that idea to create stories from your own family history? There is enough context that you could also look at the merchant trade in the early 20th Century; Jewish history; the creation of Israel, among others. You can also have fun with many of the Yiddish terms ... how many have become mainstream sayings/cliche?

Reading Level:
4.9
Recommended Age To Read By Yourself:
8 to 12
Recommended Age To Read Together:
5 to 10
Age of child:
Read with 7-year-old girl.
Purchase Recommendation:
Borrow. This is a fun story to read at any season, but particularly around Passover.
Little Kid Reaction:

Our daughter followed along, and had lots of questions about some of the words (crooks, garments, workhouse, trolley car, tummel). She thought the sidebars about what should happen to the robbers was funny.

Parent Reaction:

This is an enjoyable, clever, albeit wordy, story. There are lots of asides, and after a while, the humor is lost. The author uses questions, but they are clearly rhetorical, touched with some sarcasm. The illustrations are clever and add personality to the tale.

Pros:

Everyone can enjoy this story about Passover. It offers some wonderful, informative tidbits about Passover, Jewish history, and the Old Testament.

Cons:

It reads almost too colloquial, like its meant only for a niche audience, not a universal one.


Title Shlemiel Crooks
About
Author Anna Olswanger
Publisher Newsouth, Inc. © 2005
Illustrators Paula Goodman Koz
ISBN 158838165X
Material Hard Cover
Cost $15.95
Genres Picture Book, Cultures And Tradition, Humor, Historical Fiction, Judaism, History - 1900-1919
Other Reviews:

More Reviews

Here are some other books we have reviewed that you may like!

BOOK REVIEW

Author
Julie Baer
Publisher
Bollix Books © 2003
ISBN
1932188002

BOOK REVIEW

Author
Libby Sternberg
Publisher
Bancroft Press © 2007
ISBN
1890862517

BOOK REVIEW

Author
Eric A Kimmel
Publisher
Holiday House © 1989
ISBN
9780823407699