Tell Me Another Scary Story ... But Not Too Scary!


One Halloween Eve, a young boy got the scare of his life. His neighbor, Mr. Neewalloh (Halloween backwards) was making a costume for him. When the young boy went over to see him, Mr. Neewalloh wasn't there to meet him at the door. When he went to the basement, he found Mr. Neewalloh on the floor, next to Dracula, and covered in blood. Or was it ketchup?

Reader Enjoyment Factors:

Halloween costumes, a friendly neighbor, and a few surprises add to the suspense of this seasonal story for kids.

Content Awareness Factors:

The book jacket makes a big deal about the author reading the story. Reiner does a great job reading (as you would expect) but he also ad libs from the text. If you are thinking about using the audio to help with a read-along, this is not the book for that.

Little Kid Reaction

Our daughter loves this book. She read it to us on the way home from the bookstore and has read or listened along multiple times for days on end. When she found it in the bookstore, she looked at the pages and quickly flipped to the last page to see how it ended.

Parent Reaction

When my daughter opened to the page with Mr. Neewollah on the floor and the sentence "it was real blood," I got a little worried. So I flipped to the last page, too. There is a happy ending - and in fact Reiner is offering kids a lesson about how to call for help in an emergency. All in all, this is a story with just-the-right amount of suspense and "gore" that kids crave at Halloween.

Type of Book:
This picture book story offers suspense and opportunities for kids to bail from the story. It comes with a CD.
Educational Themes:

Although this is meant largely to be a scary story for kids, the author does a nice job connecting the scary part with something kids need to know: how to recognize an emergency and call for help.

Reading Level:
Recommended Age To Read By Yourself:
7 to 10
Recommended Age To Read Together:
5 to 8
Age of child:
Read with and by an 8-year-old girl.
Purchase Recommendation:
Borrow. This is a fun story, but it isn't one that you'd consider a family classic.

Title Tell Me Another Scary Story ... but Not Too Scary!
Author Carl Reiner
Publisher Phoenix Books © 2009
Illustrators James Bennett
ISBN 9781597776301
Material Hard Cover
Cost $16.95
Genres Halloween
Other Reviews:

More Reviews

Here are some other books we have reviewed that you may like!


Sheila Sauvageau-Smestad
Better Be Write Publishing, LLC © 2005
be the star you are


Doug Cushman
Harpercollins Childrens Books, a Division of HarperCollins Publishing © 2006


Laurel Snyder
Tricycle Press © 2008