The Day I Swapped My Dad For Two Goldfish


The kids are divided. Older brother has the fantastically brilliant idea of trading his father for two goldfish; his little sister disagrees. Once the deal is struck - and discovered by mom! - the two siblings start a journey from friend to friend, house to house, trading along the way all the wonderful things that one would trade for a "Dad." Through the eyes of a child, the logic of the trades cannot be denied, and in the end, we find the father a fair trade for [sorry, we won't tell you.]

Reader Enjoyment Factors:

The story is a witty and funny look at two siblings who aren’t necessarily getting along; but nevertheless share a journey to bring their father home. Uncommonly, the two siblings remain unnamed in the book - allowing children reading/hearing the story to more easily identify with the characters.

Content Awareness Factors:

Interestingly, the one possible con would be that I almost passed this book up when I flipped through the pages and saw the dark (in color only) graphic novel styling. That having been said, this style works wonderfully with the story, and having read it I can’t see it being done in any another way.

Little Kid Reaction

The kids giggle all the way through this book, which took a while to read because the mixed media images were so much fun to look at. My daughter especially liked the role of the little sister, who turns out to be the wise one. She had many comments after the story in vigorous protest to trading a dad for two goldfish… "I would never do that!.." and many small comments while we were reading meant to hint at her utter support of the little sister's role in the story.

Parent Reaction

I loved this book. I was as immersed in the incredible idea of being able to trade an adult authority figure away if I wished so - as was my five-year-old co-reader. Then, as the story progressed, I was happily reminded of the interactions and bantering that goes on between a younger sister and older brother (having been the younger sister myself…). Some of the best humor is in the illustrations, and these should not be overlooked lest you miss the joke!

Type of Book:
This is humorous look at sibling rivalry, consequences, and value.
Educational Themes:

While it is a wonderful escape from reality imagining you could trade your Dad (or any authority figure) for two small goldfish, the bigger lesson was that sibling is pretty normal and it’s OK to feel it sometimes. The last time I myself was reminded so happy about this eternal cycle was reading Shel Siverstein (" … one crying and spying young sister for sale … ").

Reading Level:
Recommended Age To Read By Yourself:
8 to 12
Recommended Age To Read Together:
4 to 8
Age of child:
Read with a 5-year-old girl who has an older brother.
Purchase Recommendation:
Buy. This is a wonderful book to get for any parent or guardian who shares their world with multiple kids; I would buy it for a family member even more so - especially my older brother! Read this to all brothers and sisters (especially if the sister is yo

Title The Day I Swapped My Dad for Two Goldfish
Author Neil Gaiman
Publisher HarperCollins Publishers © 2004
Illustrators Dave McKean
ISBN 9780060587017
Material Hard Cover
Cost $16.95
Genres Family, Humor
Reminder: Cover images, and links are affiliate links. The Reading Tub can earn income via purchases made via these links. 100% of any income goes directly to our literacy mission.
Other Reviews:

You May Also Like...

Check out these books you may also like


Tom Lichtenheld
Little, Brown Books for Young Readers © 2005


Jules Feiffer
Disney-Hyperion, Disney Book Group © 2004


Cynthia Dwyer
Thumbprint Press © 2006