The Wishing Flower (Second Edition)

Summary:

King John and Queen Alexandra watch over the magical kingdom of Laven-Cleve. They are good rulers. King John works side-by-side with villagers to build and repair their homes. Queen Alexandra help the residents, too. No one has any worries here, but something is missing: children. On one of her walks, Queen Alexandra found a beautiful flower. The flower would grant a wish, but only for her. Every time she tried to wish for children in the village, the flower turned her down. Will Laven-Cleve always be the kingdom without kids?


Reader Enjoyment Factors:

Children will enjoy this fairy tale about a magical kingdom. Parents of adoptive families may enjoy this allegory about children, families, and wishes come true.

Content Awareness Factors:

The graphics detract from the story, which is meant to be illustrated. The fairy tale will interest young readers/listeners, but is probably beyond most of the audience at this reading level (sixth grade).


Little Kid Reaction

Our child asked lots of questions and let us finish reading, but she didn't like the book. She kept asking why the pictures were blurred. The presentation distracted her from the story.

Parent Reaction

What first caught my eye in this story is the vocabulary. Vortex, prosperity and inhabitants are not words you routinely see in picture books. I liked that the story's theme was accessible to younger children, but readable by older kids. Ultimately, though, I'm not sure that worked. The story got bogged down and named characters emerge on the last page. The computer-generated graphics detract from the story's theme of a magical kingdom. Some were blurry and may have been enlarged too much.

Type of Book:
This is an illustrated fairy tale for upper elementary students.
Educational Themes:

The story presents an interesting question about choices, selfishness, and selflessness. When Queen Alexandra could not make a wish for everyone, was she selfish to keep the wishing flower in her garden? Fairy tales are wonderful tools for sparking imagination. Give kids the opportunity to create their own "kingdom." What would it be like? What kind of rules would they have?

Reading Level:
4.9
Recommended Age To Read By Yourself:
9 to 12
Recommended Age To Read Together:
6 to 12
Age of child:
Read with 6-year-old child.
Purchase Recommendation:
Borrow. There are other, stronger stories that offer valuable life lessons in fairy-tale themes.

Title The Wishing Flower
Author Mosetta Penick Phillips-Cermak
Publisher Avid Readers Publishing Group © 2008 (Second Edition)
Illustrators Mosetta M. Penick Phillips-Cermak
ISBN 9780980143874
Material Hard Cover
Cost $16.50
Genres Fairy Tale
Reminder: Cover images, amazon.com and indiebound.org links are affiliate links. The Reading Tub can earn income via purchases made via these links. 100% of any income goes directly to our literacy mission.
Other Reviews:

You May Also Like...

Check out these books you may also like

BOOK REVIEW

Author
Frances Gilbert
Publisher
Greene Bark Press © 2000
ISBN
1880851601

BOOK REVIEW

Author
Frank B Stockton
Publisher
Candlewick Press, Walker Books Group © 2004
ISBN
0763622397

BOOK REVIEW

Author
Diane Carr, Kira Earley
Publisher
Jawbone Publishing Corporation © 2004
ISBN
1590940245
be the star you are